SushiAddiction

big thanks or th list...

ound many nw (and old) mangas to ollow ...

(hll, my kyboard is diing ... many kys wont work anymor ... )

Then take this list that I compile from my personal archive and the one with batoto link sorted with no duplicate from the above list, most of it have fantasy like feeling or isekai atmosphere in it and I'll add a short discription based on my memory.

https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/hero-union-bbs-r12956 heroes from all over the parallel world using massage board complaining, arguing, joking and give advice about their daily life as the heroes.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/dungeon-meshi-r13871dungeon, monster, cook, eat, sleep, repeat. but there's elf in it and that's good.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/blue-dragon-ral-ω-grado-r1198oh no, not that blue ass gay shadow dragon shit. lewd content.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/blade♥play-r6758the girls were turned into demons! go save them with your holy dick... sword, I mean holy sword! (not available on batoto though)
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/hero-sama-how-is-the-water-r20615 the demon lord has been defeated, the hero with the least contribution on the war was forced to work at a hotspring resort, stuff happen with loli demon.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/yuusha-ga-shinda-murabito-no-ore-ga-hotta-otoshiana-ni-yuusha-ga-ochita-kekka-r14527you accidentally killed the hero! take the role! save the world with your tsundere childhood friend.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/sekai-no-owari-no-encore-r17000party roster: arch angel, demon queen, dragon princess, knigth A. basically the mc is weak while the other member op.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/sayonara-ryuusei-konnichiwa-jinsei-r18991ancient dragon killed by dragon slayer clan, no regret whatsoever, reincarnated as a male human.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/dragons-houagase-hunting-r21782you spend your days doing nothing and your family is tired of your shit, so your father decide to kick you out of the house, and now you on a quest to find a new home for you to live in, imagine that... but you are a dragon.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/simply-good-taste-for-a-dukes-daughter-r17720 isekai shoujo.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/maou-no-hisho-r20764 your secretary is so good at doing her job that you feel threaten by it. except you are a demon lord and your secretary is a human girl you kidnaped on a whim and her job is helping you conquering the human kingdoms.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/its-my-life-r18491 a light fantasy manga about retired knight captain and a girl he stumble upon.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/tokiwa-kitareri-r14455 the setting is in modern japan, there's magic, cyborg, ninjas and the whole thing is mixed together that it created something unusual chaotic but you can somehow enjoy it, you know "Gate and JSDF who fough there" yeah it's something like that. ah but there's an elf girl in it.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/sodatechimaou-r21513 3 demon king found a lost human child, and they decide to look after it. what could go wrong?
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/nectar-of-dharani-r20234you were summoned to another world where you have to figth evil and suck tits!
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/raisekamika-r20624 honestly I don't know why I have the file of this one, but it seems it was something about fighting in another world.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/ascendance-of-a-bookworm-r18488 a nerd librarian on another world, shoujo manga.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/mairimashita-iruma-kun-r21063 iruma-kun were sold by his parent to a demon. a demon with job of a headmaster of demons school and that iruma have to enter it too.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/tsuyokute-new-saga-r12329 the hero defeated the demon king but with a great price, get a chance to redo his life and get back to the past to change the outcome of the war with the demons.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/the-mage-will-master-magic-efficiently-in-his-second-life-r17812 it's like the hero above, but this one was a mage
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/12-beast-r8357 monster girls are on the verge of extinction because of the invasion of humans, figth the other human and claim the girls!
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/elf-san-wa-yaserarenai-r20380 reverse isekai, the elf girl visit our world.
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/cylciacode-r21774 god decide to play a prank by merging the reality and your game world into one using some mysterious world wide holographic projector and trap you soul into the body of character from the game. not a god though, just some rich bastard with the resource to do so,
https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/maou-jou-de-oyasumi-r19193the type of princess who would start the second holocaust just so she can get a good night sleep.
 
Would be nice if we get to know and get more of this fantasy and isekai stuff.

you have my gratitude, great job!

Finally i don't have to enter the scary search tool

https://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/rain-r2575

possible isekai manga, there scene where rain encounter a forbidden area/dimension where he see the ruin of the landmark or structure from earth (eifel tower, pyramid, pagoda tower I kinda forgot) and somehow I got the feeling that rain know whats up or have the memory and knowlege of it, like you know (their world was like build from the ruin of earh, or second earth some stuff like that) and the protagonist have issue with their world origin or purpose.

ty for the list. I've read them all.

*snip*

thanks for this.

why they still refuse to add an isekai (or equivalent) tag is beyond me

​

Problems I see that would not be clear that aren't reincarnation/summoning/transporting​ as you'd expect, no Isekai.

 

Reincarnated but not other world

​Is it really another world?

​??? gain memories of past life or other

I think the biggest potential problem is covering series like Sayonara Ryuusei which are "Isekai-ish" but not actually "Isekai". Readers should ideally be able to filter series like that out, but it also wouldn't make sense to place Isekai on them. There's real trouble here in that I feel like a lot of these series are linked by content and style rather than actual genre, if that makes sense, but I don't think there's an elegant way to handle this. I think to an extent these have to be accepted as a lost cause.

The tag itself, though...

The vagueness itself is probably fine, since "Isekai" is a super open-ended idea to begin with, and I think the community will do a decent job of handling the tags. Isekai is about as subtle as a bull in a china shop. As long as the genre description is not needlessly tight, it'll likely get handled fine, essentially running along the lines of "A series where the main character has an origin, knowledge or common sense stemming from another universe/world." This covers the majority of edge cases, though there would need to be explicit consideration for cases like VRMMO. Essentially it would need to be decided whether the focus of the "Isekai" tag would lie on the setting (dude in another world) or the content (dude using "earth common sense" to interact with predominantly fantasy setting people/creatures).

I'm not really sure how to handle cases like VRMMO, honestly. I feel like the tag wouldn't fit in that case, but if it were a little more shounen-style and harem-esque I'd probably feel it would. I feel like considerable discussion would be needed to solve the nature of these "real" edge cases.

The most complete thing to do would be content tags (as you noted), but barring that the next closest would be a genre tag along the lines of reversing time/being reborn/returning to an earlier state/etc. in order to fully split the broad "isekai zone" into "reborn, same world", "reborn, different world" and "different world". But this would also (arguably) add some unnecessary tags and just make things cumbersome.

Either way I think there's a strong argument for the "Isekai" tag to be made. The flood of content coming out from it as a pseudo-genre demands some kind of response, I think. When we've got a series about a dude dying and turning into a hot spring, you know that the genre saturation is extreme. Particularly because some people will want to search up or avoid isekai content, especially in conjunction with other tags ie: ecchi.