51 replies to this topic

[Diwrno]

If you are not sure if a comic you want to add is appropriate or not you can ask here.

If you have seen a comic that you think is not appropriate, you can report that here as well.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read this before you request anything, please:

Before you ask here, please check Mangaupdates.
They are usually very good with their generes.
If the series you want to add is listed as Adult, Borderline-Hentai or Hentai or something along those lines, chances are high, that it is not allowed here.
For now I consider the genre Smut as orange it's not exactly red but could be.

Also Lolicon is an absolute no go! We will be strict about that.

But if you are still not sure about it or think it is fine despite the genre tag (or you think it doesn't deserve the tag at all) it got there, feel free to ask about it.

I'm going to inline edit with red(=not appropriate) or green(=appropriate) and I encourage other moderators to do the same.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
General information regarding this topic:
by funnybunnylogic. Original post
And as far as the restriction of what is too mature for Batoto? Perhaps I can clarify the restrictions a bit more.

• Is genitalia shown (e.g., penis or vagina)
• Are children being exploited?
• Are there explicit sex scenes (i.e., very little or nothing at all is left to the imagination)?
• Are there excessive sex scenes (i.e., every chapter has a sex scene, or most chapters focus on sexual acts)?
• Does the comic possess redeeming qualities beyond the sexual content (i.e., is it merely fapping material, or does it have an actual storyline and plot)?
• Does the sexual content enrich the storyline, or is it simply for pornographic purposes?[/font]
• Do you think that you would be grounded for life, and or killed by your parents, if you were caught showing this to your 12 to 15-year-old sibling?

If any combination of these questions are a concern in the comic, it is most likely not suitable for Batoto.

Of course, this is just a general outline of some questions you may want to ask yourself when uploading comics. The best bet is to use your common sense and think of the comic as a whole, not just the chapter you are currently uploading. After all, some comics start out vanilla and then take a dive for the perverse later on in the story.

We are planning to have a site specifically for AO Content in the future but there is nothing specific yet, so we can't give you any more details than that.
Post edited by mhh.
============================================================================================================

I want to know if some of this series can be uploaded to Batoto (my spanish fansub work in this mangas) because I dont want to upload something dont have to added to Batoto for the rules and I want to be secure about wath can/cant I upload.
Aki-Sora (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Glass no Megami (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Hajimete to,
Highschool of the Dead (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Koi wa Misoji o Sugite kara
Koi wo Suru no ga Shigoto desu (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Koibana Onsen (Im sure, I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Love Junkies (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Nozoki Ana (Im sure, I cant upload this manga to Batoto) Previous stance on this: not appropriate - mhh
Sense (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Usotsuki Paradox (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Velvet Kiss (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto) Not appropriate - mhh

Edited by mhh, 05 November 2011 - 05:16 PM.

[Loki]

I want to know if some of this series can be uploaded to Batoto (my spanish fansub work in this mangas) because I dont want to upload something dont have to added to Batoto for the rules and I want to be secure about wath can/cant I upload.

Aki-Sora (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Glass no Megami (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Hajimete to,
Highschool of the Dead (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Koi wa Misoji o Sugite kara
Koi wo Suru no ga Shigoto desu (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Koibana Onsen (Im sure, I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Love Junkies (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Nozoki Ana (Im sure, I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Sense (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Usotsuki Paradox (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)
Velvet Kiss (Im not sure, but I think I cant upload this manga to Batoto)

besides highschool of the dead , i'm pretty sure the others are not allowed , i can state that for some with certainty but the rest are based on demographics , because i havent read them

[hados9]

And can i say for Aki-sora that is basicly Hentai with a story behind it so that cant be uploaded here for a while

[Departure]

Question, would Dee Love - Ayu no Monogatari, I'm overruling myself since I gave the whole topic a thought and decided I haven't read enough of the "Deep Love series to really judge them. They do not have any of the above mentioned tags only "mature" so I'm allowing them. Sorry for the confusion Akio_NE - mhh(in it's defense I would to add that there's more to that. There's actually a story behind of it all. I mean it's based on a novel after all. I can't remember how many explicit scenes there are in the manga, I'll have to re-read it again to remember. But it is what it is I guess.)
Deep Love - Reina no Unmei, See above -mhh
Deep Love - Host See above - mhh
Haou Airen ( I am still considering uploading this title, but I'm not sure if it's okay to upload)
Hot Gimmick (I'll upload this title seems to be okay, compare to other titles that I've seen here)




be to explicit for batoto, or can I upload them?

Forget the deep-love series, this really isn't my forte. I've looked for something that comes close to the deep-love series and I couldn't find anything that even comes close here in batoto. I guess I'll just scratch those three titles out of the list.

Edited by mhh, 05 November 2011 - 04:06 PM.

[mhh]

I'm going to move other post here from threads where they should (theoretically) not be.

[Departure]

sorry for not posting in the right place =(, but could someone let me know if I could upload those series or not?

[mhh]

sorry for not posting in the right place =(, but could someone let me know if I could upload those series or not?

No problem at all, there wasn't really a place for it yet so I made one.
I will most likely not have time to review much of this right now I hope somebody else will be stepping in.

[Grumpy]

Basically, if there's
"adult" genre and "borderline-h" on MU, it's most likely not acceptable here. Borderline-H is really far beyond the borderline by everyone but japan's standards. lol

[KidCongo]

Then again, we have Yuria 100 Shiki and Mahou Onna ga Kuru!!, so...

[mhh]

Updated the first post, and I will also look into things requested here. But I can't promise to get everything done.

As mentioned above:

Adult, Borderline-H, Hentai not allowed.

Exceptions to that rule can be requested here. That counts for all of the above mentioned as well. Unless there has been a specific edit made.

[Seraphic Mist]

I need a second opinion on Ichinensei ni Nacchattara.

While it's tagged as a Lolicon manga in MangaUpdates, as such it isn't a Lolicon centric manga - it's just a partial sub-plot (one of the main non-protagonist characters is a Lolicon) and fan-service exists - without being too lolicon fanservice centric or excessively sexual, but people could disagree on any, or all counts.

Just to be on the safer side, I'd appreciate feedback on whether it's appropriate to upload to Batoto, as I'm not sure whether it falls below Borderline acceptable or not.

EDIT: Alright, thanks KidCongo.

Edited by Shadowed Fate, 13 November 2011 - 04:54 PM.

[KidCongo]

What mhh wrote in the comment section of Ichinensei ni Nacchattara should be applicable.

[hero]

I would like to know if I can add those two manga;Gold (FUJITA Kazuko) and Silver (FUJITA Kazuko).

[mhh]

I would like to know if I can add those two manga;Gold (FUJITA Kazuko) and Silver (FUJITA Kazuko).

I can't say I have read enough to judge them but yes, they should both be fine.

Silver didn't fall under any of the generes/categories mentioned so you could have just uploaded it. Asking is if you have serious doubts weather the content you want to upload is suitable or not.

Edited by mhh, 15 November 2011 - 04:48 PM.

[KidCongo]

I'd like a second opinion on Bloody Mary and - even though the chapters are in Italian - My Balls/Oretama.

Edited by KidCongo, 16 November 2011 - 11:27 AM.

[FunnyBunnyLogic]

During my quick glance through Bloody Mary, I was treated to several female full-frontal shots, numerous intimate scenes, including a rather provocative piercing of Mary's labia... and this is the content from chapters one and two. Considering the graphic nature of the series, I would guess that it is only going to get worse and perhaps even pornographic from here onwards. However, my review may be biased or unfair, so I would suggest that one of the other moderators reviews the series and provides their own opinion.

As for My Balls/Oretama, I don't have any constructive feedback in regards to this series... other than the fact that I dropped it like a hot potato because I thought it was stupid and it seemed like one of the characters was a loli... even more reason to drop it. However, in all fairness we may want to have one of the other moderators review this title as well... perhaps even check out the English chapters available elsewhere to get an idea of the story's content.

[mhh]

They are both labeled "Adult" on Mangaupdates. And My Balls/Oretama is also taged with "Borderline-H". I'm not so sure about Bloody Mary but I don't think My Balls should be up.

[Colour]

They are both labeled "Adult" on Mangaupdates. And My Balls/Oretama is also taged with "Borderline-H". I'm not so sure about Bloody Mary but I don't think My Balls should be up.

Oretama really shouldn't be on here mhh. Its boarder line-H with basically every chapter having excessive sex scenes that seem to get worse as it progresses.

Edited by Censored, 18 November 2011 - 02:58 AM.

[manga2x]

Do you host licensed mangas?
I have plenty old mangas on cd or dvd.
I'll help upload them to batoto if they are ok and if someone wants to read it
I can't upload them all. that will take crazy amount of my time.
That's why only if someone wants it.
if no one ask then i won't upload, since no one bother to read them anyway

Here is a bit of my collection
Arakure (Complete)
Ayashi no ceres
Angel sanctuary (This is incest manga)
Chobits (Complete)
Flame of recca (Complete)
Ranma 1/2 (Complete)
Rurounin Kenshin (Complete)
IS (Complete)
Please save my earth (Complete)
Salad days (Complete)

[Loki]

It depends , we host licensed series that are scanlations only and if the groups that have done those scanlations agrees on sharing their licensed works.
There are also mature issues to look out for as well and official scans by english publishers which are a no-no here.