205 replies to this topic

[Pasteduck]

The chances of ToG being animated are slim. Why? No fan service! There are no boobie monsters or panty shots anywhere to be seen!

And I never got why Freezing or Black God got animated in the first place? Its not like they were very good? But they did have lots of fanservice!

Dude I loved freezing it was epic sauce with side of Dayum! The ani me was horrible...and well I find your post just insulting. ToG doesn't need fan service. It's awesome on it's own. Not to mention it has way to many metro's >.>

I agree that ToG doesn't need any fan service. There are more than enough anime that doesn't have fan service that are good.

[Myki]

Have a long list of manhwaS I'd love to see animated! ToG, Noblesse, Tal, Let's Fight Ghost, Kubara, Trace, Pinocchio.....stop me now! Maybe someday!

[Antisolar]

Hope there will never any anime version of ToG.
Cuz as said anime are just destroying paper version. I've read some comics (like 250 ?) and I never see an anime adaptation(I didn't search for 250 adaptation though) that didn't modified the story. Add of fanservice, censure, complete changes in the story...
Actualy I've only see only one good anime adaptation and it was Elfen Lied. And of course there are a lot difference between the anime and the scans.. But Elfen Lied could made cry su much I had hard times to breath.
And also only one anime version better than the scan version : Code Geass. And if I'm not mistaken the scan version is the(bad?) adaptation of the anime.

Now, I only watch anime that seem to follow the scan, like Naruto (but well, they modified the Naruto VS Pain fight so much it was not the universe of Naruto anymore) or anime that are not the adaptation of any scan.
Adaptation from novel or visual novel are fine too, like Bakemonogotari or Type Moon's.

But ToG is just marvelous. Unless the anime adaptation is perfect, unless there is no change, it would only hurt (a lot of people including me) to see.
It will never appens because the ones in charge of adaptations seek audiance and money. If they have to made Baam's face in Yuri's breasts instead of Yuri's foot in Baam's face, in order to get more people addicted, they will do it.
I don't want that. Baam would, but not me.

[gus]

it true what you said the quality of anime have drop over the year they are just making anime at random half the time the story is not that good i haven't seen an anime of my liking since e7 and blood+ then when i read ToG i just couldn't help to want an anime based on this awesome story

[Cell]

What you need in situations like that, are the creator and animation group working together. Having them strictly focus on the story line, and any slight deviations the author approves of.
Also you need a good animation group, and not one that will degrade the quality of animation for time.
All of which can be specified in a contract.

What I would really, REALLY, hate to see is all the cliche bullshit.
I also dislike the use of honorifics. Yes they may speak like that in Asian cultures, but not everyone does. It's too cheesy, and again cliche.

There is that risk that an anime adptation would lower the quality of the story.

[Noodlepirate]

To make an anime would require the creators involvement which would slow down releases of this great series.
I say no thanks. Maybe when the series is over or in like it's 6th+ season.

[Cascascap]

Hope there will never any anime version of ToG.
Cuz as said anime are just destroying paper version. I've read some comics (like 250 ?) and I never see an anime adaptation(I didn't search for 250 adaptation though) that didn't modified the story. Add of fanservice, censure, complete changes in the story...
Actualy I've only see only one good anime adaptation and it was Elfen Lied. And of course there are a lot difference between the anime and the scans.. But Elfen Lied could made cry su much I had hard times to breath.
And also only one anime version better than the scan version : Code Geass. And if I'm not mistaken the scan version is the(bad?) adaptation of the anime.

Now, I only watch anime that seem to follow the scan, like Naruto (but well, they modified the Naruto VS Pain fight so much it was not the universe of Naruto anymore) or anime that are not the adaptation of any scan.
Adaptation from novel or visual novel are fine too, like Bakemonogotari or Type Moon's.

But ToG is just marvelous. Unless the anime adaptation is perfect, unless there is no change, it would only hurt (a lot of people including me) to see.
It will never appens because the ones in charge of adaptations seek audiance and money. If they have to made Baam's face in Yuri's breasts instead of Yuri's foot in Baam's face, in order to get more people addicted, they will do it.
I don't want that. Baam would, but not me.

Well Air gear adaptations is great, but they dont finish the manga is too long

[Yu Han Sung]

Oh and just thought of this:

Even if TOG were to be adapted to an anime, I think SIU will have little say in the process.

[Urek Mazino]

Oh and just thought of this:

Even if TOG were to be adapted to an anime, I think SIU will have little say in the process.

Agreed but another thought, they could use fillers to add the information from the author's blog, fillers actually being canon

[Hazai]

It will probably never happen because there needs to a major following in japan for it to happen. The manhwa's mentioned before got animated because they were published in Japan. It's a wonder why there hasn't been an Korean animation companies that have popped up, with so much anime being drawn by Koreans. Probably because of Korea's vastly smaller population than Japan thus not getting enough support to make a money from it.

[Cʜɪʟʟɪɴ_Pᴀɴᴅᴀ]

I think an anime version of Tower of god would be wonderful but as Hanzai said it is unlikely to happen. Maybe after the whole story completed they can consider to make it an anime but i think it is still unlikely cause if i were the author i would prefer starting new manhwa series instead of making it anime.

Edited by mfozgur, 14 March 2012 - 02:11 PM.

[Yu Han Sung]

It will probably never happen because there needs to a major following in japan for it to happen. The manhwa's mentioned before got animated because they were published in Japan. It's a wonder why there hasn't been an Korean animation companies that have popped up, with so much anime being drawn by Koreans. Probably because of Korea's vastly smaller population than Japan thus not getting enough support to make a money from it.

Well, I also heard that piracy is really bad in South Korea and even one manhwa author admitted to pirating lots of stuff. But she got a rude shock when she saw her works online too.

[DragonshadowEX]

Well, I also heard that piracy is really bad in South Korea and even one manhwa author admitted to pirating lots of stuff. But she got a rude shock when she saw her works online too.

kinda explains why a place like naver which lets you see the manhwa for free exists. thx, I never knew that pirating was a big problem in Korea

[Yu Han Sung]

kinda explains why a place like naver which lets you see the manhwa for free exists. thx, I never knew that pirating was a big problem in Korea

Huh? Their webcomics section is no different from many other online comics portals/sites like Keenspot, Smackjeeves and many other sites, etc. The only difference is they cleverly targetted different demographics via many different types of webcomics.

In fact, they might be selling merchandise based on that series or a franchise.

Edited by Yu Han Sang, 14 March 2012 - 04:03 PM.

[DragonshadowEX]

Huh? Their webcomics section is no different from many other online comics portals/sites like Keenspot, Smackjeeves and many other sites, etc. The only difference is they cleverly targetted different demographics via many different types of webcomics.

In fact, they might be selling merchandise based on that series or a franchise.

sorry, I meant that letting people see mangas for free is kind of pointless in a place with no piracy but if piracy is massively rampant that trying to make people pay for manga/manhwa/webcomics becomes fruitless then you have to turn to other ways to make money from those manhwas/mangas/webcomics. In other words your comment made me think about why writers would let people read their works for free

edit: my comment was more targeted toward manga artists letting their works be shown for free rather than sites

Edited by DragonshadowEX, 14 March 2012 - 04:23 PM.

[papasmourf]

well i also would love to see TOG become an anime or even better an RPG or MMORPG. as for the anime my only fear would be if the stoped it early as it happend in other anime such as berserk which also was a manwha(well that was due to extrime violence) claymore and many many more anime.

well i also would love to see TOG become an anime or even better an RPG or MMORPG. as for the anime my only fear would be if the stoped it early as it happend in other anime such as berserk which also was a manwha(well that was due to extrime violence) claymore and many many more anime.

[Jackob]

well i also would love to see TOG become an anime or even better an RPG or MMORPG. as for the anime my only fear would be if the stoped it early as it happend in other anime such as berserk which also was a manwha(well that was due to extrime violence) claymore and many many more anime.

well i also would love to see TOG become an anime or even better an RPG or MMORPG. as for the anime my only fear would be if the stoped it early as it happend in other anime such as berserk which also was a manwha(well that was due to extrime violence) claymore and many many more anime.

Berserk is not a manwa but a manga, sacrilège !
Also it would be difficult for TOG to become a game (chances of getting tog anime are areoung 0%) without changing it's main fonctions.

[101010]

There is a thread about ToG being made into a MMORPG. Refer to it if you want to discuss the matter.

http://vatoto.com/forums/topic/6748-tog-mmorpg/

[kshin]

2 naver webtoons became animes.

What ones?

[Sizel]

What ones?

I believe one is called Miho Story and another something horse store.

Make that three.

Welcome! Convience store.