13 replies to this topic

[Ifrittuccia]

As the title I can not comment under the following manga :

 

http://vatoto.com/comic/_/comics/tate-no-yuusha-no-nariagari-r12672

 

 

I checked if I have the same problem in other manga, but it only happens here.
It's normal?
Can it be solved? O.o

[You]

Seems like this particular comic has been locked for some unknown reason. Looks like you can still post in the comic threads atm though...
It can be solved by a mod/Admin unlocking it if they feel like it

[Ifrittuccia]

Why they are due to arrive in locked this comic? O.O
I do not think I ever read something so terrible and it is also the first time I've seen it happen.
It can only moderators or admins of the site this thing? °-°

[svines85]

Please read the rules regarding the comic comment section.

 

https://vatoto.com/forums/topic/18007-must-read-comment-sections-rules-and-guidelines/

 

The bottom line is that practically none of what's going on in the comic comment sections (this one included) is supposed to be going on, at all according to the site's rules. It's what the forum section is for.

 

And I'll just say, Batoto has one of the best forum sections you'll ever find on pretty much any kind of site, manga composite reader sites obviously included, and it's a damned shame to have watched it whither away because of the decisions this site has made in allowing those comic comment sections to become such unregulated madhouses. 

 

I'm glad........very glad.........to see that comment section closed down, and I wish they'd do away with them entirely.

[NZPIEFACE]

Please read the rules regarding the comic comment section.

 

https://vatoto.com/forums/topic/18007-must-read-comment-sections-rules-and-guidelines/

 

The bottom line is that practically none of what's going on in the comic comment sections (this one included) is supposed to be going on, at all according to the site's rules. It's what the forum section is for.

 

And I'll just say, Batoto has one of the best forum sections you'll ever find on pretty much any kind of site, manga composite reader sites obviously included, and it's a damned shame to have watched it whither away because of the decisions this site has made in allowing those comic comment sections to become such unregulated madhouses. 

 

I'm glad........very glad.........to see that comment section closed down, and I wish they'd do away with them entirely.

So, what are comments supposed to be?
I see comments related either directly to the series, or comments directly related to the comments.

 

The spoilers from the webnovel are all in spoilers, and nothing was too out of hand, nor were they spamming pics.

Even the guy on the second page who had a picture not in a spoiler box was only because he forgot to create a proper box.

[OMGWTFBBQPONIES]

There are multiple removed comments on the latest page alone there. I assume it's either a temporary lock for cleaning up or a lock to make people calm down (not sure what discussions were going on there + cbb to check).

it is also the first time I've seen it happen.

There are many comics with locked comments .-.
Though at least so far it's primarily been a side effect of locking comic data edits because of edit wars (edit button replaced with "You cannot edit this comic" message; comment section is tied to that lock unfortunately), or the whole comic getting locked because of dmca/nsfw/whatever.

 

Recently there have been a few comment locks of popular comics which had multiple reports from users about the chaos going on in them, I think either to clean said places up or to make people move to comic subora where the majority of what they commented with should be in the first place (or both). Not 100% sure, /me is not a comic/comment mod.

spoilers from the webnovel are all in spoilers

there's also a possibility of the mod who locked it adding spoiler tags themselves. no "edited by" notes for comments.

no idea if this is the case here of course.

 

 

 

====

aaaand it's open now.

Edited by OMGWTFBBQPONIES, 08 March 2017 - 05:05 AM.

[svines85]

I see comments related either directly to the series, or comments directly related to the comments.

 

So, you did read the link I posted... " [Must read] Comment Sections' Rules and Guidelines" ...?

 

Did you happen to note the one that said " 2.If posting Plot Details, use (Spoiler] Tags, or move it to the Forums instead." and actually stop to think what it meant? It means you can not discuss the comic at all in that section.........any "plot details"......... i.e. anything that could possibly spoil a new reader coming to that page who hasn't read any of it short of putting every single word inside spoiler tags.

 

Get the idea? Why do you think I said that all that's going on in those comment sections needed to be going on in the forums? Not to mention the fact that those comment sections don't reflect anywhere (think how the forums actually do have a place where all the activity shows) so nobody that isn't already following the comic ever freaking knows what's popular to discuss around here and can go and check out the story they're seeing all that talk going on about.

 

Again, as I said, a damned shame, they should've done away with 'em 3 years ago when they figured out they were ungovernable and instead they caved into the pressure of catering to a tiny, loud and whiny,  fraction of the membership. 

[NZPIEFACE]

So, you did read the link I posted... " [Must read] Comment Sections' Rules and Guidelines" ...?

 

Did you happen to note the one that said " 2.If posting Plot Details, use (Spoiler] Tags, or move it to the Forums instead." and actually stop to think what it meant? It means you can not discuss the comic at all in that section.........any "plot details"......... i.e. anything that could possibly spoil a new reader coming to that page who hasn't read any of it short of putting every single word inside spoiler tags.

 

Get the idea? Why do you think I said that all that's going on in those comment sections needed to be going on in the forums? Not to mention the fact that those comment sections don't reflect anywhere (think how the forums actually do have a place where all the activity shows) so nobody that isn't already following the comic ever freaking knows what's popular to discuss around here and can go and check out the story they're seeing all that talk going on about.

 

Again, as I said, a damned shame, they should've done away with 'em 3 years ago when they figured out they were ungovernable and instead they caved into the pressure of catering to a tiny, loud and whiny,  fraction of the membership. 

Most of the comments don't even have details.
They're just ambiguous one-liners.

 

If you're going to be semantic, please realize that as long as there are no details, they can talk about what they want.

 

I'm pretty sure you know what details are.

[svines85]

Most of the comments don't even have details.
They're just ambiguous one-liners.

 

If you're going to be semantic, please realize that as long as there are no details, they can talk about what they want.

 

I'm pretty sure you know what details are.

 

Oh, I know what a fucking plot detail is, partner, it's fucking any fucking thing that happens in that story that ain't on that main comic page, and the page in question along with practically every comic comments page is still full of exactly that, plot details being openly discussed in express violation of site rules.

 

You are the perfect example of how this has come to this point.........."oh, those aren't really plot details" , "oh, they just forgot to use spoilers", "there are only a few small images, it's not like they're spamming them or something".........yeah, one of the loud, whiny  minority that just doesn't see why they shouldn't just get to do whatever they want, and pretty much fuck everybody else, right?

[NZPIEFACE]

Oh, I know what a fucking plot detail is, partner, it's fucking any fucking thing that happens in that story that ain't on that main comic page, and the page in question along with practically every comic comments page is still full of exactly that, plot details being openly discussed in express violation of site rules.

 

You are the perfect example of how this has come to this point.........."oh, those aren't really plot details" , "oh, they just forgot to use spoilers", "there are only a few small images, it's not like they're spamming them or something".........yeah, one of the loud, whiny  minority that just doesn't see why they shouldn't just get to do whatever they want, and pretty much fuck everybody else, right?

Please focus on the fact that you warped the word "plot" into "manga" at some point in your mind.

[Thiron]

Uh, going like that, is there even anything left to talk about?

 

Personally, I find the active comment section to be a unique and maybe even distinguishing feature of Batoto. On the other hand, the forums are common and exist on every reader, as well as separately. Of course, compared to the number of silent readers, both only matter to minority.

 

It doesn't seem like the moderators share my opinion, but I'd be sad if we had to constrain all discussion to forums. I like the linear chaos of comment section more than strictly divided forums.

Edited by Thiron, 08 March 2017 - 01:48 PM.

[Ifrittuccia]

There are multiple removed comments on the latest page alone there. I assume it's either a temporary lock for cleaning up or a lock to make people calm down (not sure what discussions were going on there + cbb to check).

There are many comics with locked comments .-.
Though at least so far it's primarily been a side effect of locking comic data edits because of edit wars (edit button replaced with "You cannot edit this comic" message; comment section is tied to that lock unfortunately), or the whole comic getting locked because of dmca/nsfw/whatever.

 

Recently there have been a few comment locks of popular comics which had multiple reports from users about the chaos going on in them, I think either to clean said places up or to make people move to comic subora where the majority of what they commented with should be in the first place (or both). Not 100% sure, /me is not a comic/comment mod.

there's also a possibility of the mod who locked it adding spoiler tags themselves. no "edited by" notes for comments.

no idea if this is the case here of course.

 

 

 

====

aaaand it's open now.

 

This is the first comic of those who have to follow the comments blocked.
It will be the kind that I follow recently has become so "famous" (I refer to Isekai) why there is no need to make that face.
I follow batoto about a year or maybe less so I apologize if I have not yet your own experience, I have not even noticed the battle between the comments (which will ignore these things matter).

Returning to the reason I asked is because I wanted to ask a question in the comments and not creating a topic.
My question was not about even the story, I am not with the number of volumes and just wanted to know what was the exact number of volumes in the motherland so calcolarmi what was missing so got there at the same in my country (yes I bought all 6 volumes released in my country so far and at the same time i follow here XD).
In addition there is another thing with which I am not, chapter I 31.5 I find him in volume 6, volume 8 not as it seems both posted and I wanted to see if this was an oversight group that translates it, or else.
 I ask in the comments, or you find it annoying?
I would not be a problem, I just want to know these things. '^^

Just answer my question please even close my topic, I have the impression of having created a discussion which can lead to flame seen the last useless comment. >.<

I ask again apologize for the inconvenience and thank you for the many replies.
 

[svines85]

Spoiler

This is the first comic of those who have to follow the comments blocked.
It will be the kind that I follow recently has become so "famous" (I refer to Isekai) why there is no need to make that face.
I follow batoto about a year or maybe less so I apologize if I have not yet your own experience, I have not even noticed the battle between the comments (which will ignore these things matter).

Returning to the reason I asked is because I wanted to ask a question in the comments and not creating a topic.
My question was not about even the story, I am not with the number of volumes and just wanted to know what was the exact number of volumes in the motherland so calcolarmi what was missing so got there at the same in my country (yes I bought all 6 volumes released in my country so far and at the same time i follow here XD).
In addition there is another thing with which I am not, chapter I 31.5 I find him in volume 6, volume 8 not as it seems both posted and I wanted to see if this was an oversight group that translates it, or else.
 I ask in the comments, or you find it annoying?
I would not be a problem, I just want to know these things. '^^

Just answer my question please even close my topic, I have the impression of having created a discussion which can lead to flame seen the last useless comment. >.<

I ask again apologize for the inconvenience and thank you for the many replies.

 

https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=107199

 

The latest readily available information on this title is "7 volumes (ongoing)", and the best thing to do for any questions regarding the scanlations/group scanlating it would be to contact One Time Scans directly...

 

 https://www.mangaupdates.com/groups.html?id=6134

 

I see they've got both active facebook and twitter contact points

[Ifrittuccia]

Thank you very much, I will contact the team as soon as possible.