13 replies to this topic

[gus]

so here the topic

 

do you like the 3D art in TOG

 

 

i vote no

 

reason why

 

i have seen better SIU drop the ball  in my opinion

 

 

Spoiler

Spoiler

[

/spoiler]

 

 

 

[spoiler]

the 3d art presented in TOG  is aesthetically unpleasing for me

 

i know he has to work fast but compared to the looks of the 21th FL

 

you can see were I'm coming from

Edited by gus, 03 July 2016 - 09:29 PM.

[salvatore]

I just watched the new berserk, I really like 3D, i don't know why people complain, if Tog's animation was like its trailer, i wouldn't mind it.

Edited by salvatore, 01 July 2016 - 10:12 PM.

[gus]

I just watched the new berserk, I really like 3D, i don't know why people complain, if Tog's animation was like its trailer, i wouldn't mind it.

 

 

could you send a link 

[salvatore]

could you send a link 

https://kissanime.to/Anime/Berserk-2016

[gus]

https://kissanime.to/Anime/Berserk-2016

 

thanks my argument is that it looks aesthetically unpleasing  if the assistant could work  on their drawing   for a while longer using  Photoshop

 

i wouldn't  be having this problem if  it looked finish and painted

 

 

ok here how i approached a comic i look for the art then the story

 

i choose TOG because  of the art and color palette  then the story

 

so once the story hooked me  that was a bonus

 

some of you might prefer the story first and the art being the bonus

 

but man the  landscape and color palate  during the first half of S2  wow

 

the 3d art could still look better if they painted it at least

Edited by gus, 01 July 2016 - 10:59 PM.

[salvatore]

thanks my argument is that it looks aesthetically unpleasing  if the assistant could work  on their drawing   for a while longer using  Photoshop

 

i wouldn't  be having this problem if  it looked finish and painted

No, i understand,.

 

For me my only gripe is not the art but the excessive close ups of the characters' eyes, it's like SIU is too lazy to draw their full faces. 

[gus]

No, i understand,.

 

For me my only gripe is not the art but the excessive close ups of the characters' eyes, it's like SIU is too lazy to draw their full faces. 

 

yeah  SIU choice of paneling  has made it difficult for me as well

 

i don't know why SIU switch ?

 

their alot of stuff you could do in Photoshop that let you manipilate the art  if you can't fully draw the picture

Edited by gus, 01 July 2016 - 10:57 PM.

[themantarays]

Personally, I don't mind it at all. I like how his style changes over time, and I bet he'll improve on this as well. I did love the early S2 artwork a lot, but there's been some good stuff recently as well.

[Vapid]

I just watched the new berserk, I really like 3D, i don't know why people complain, if Tog's animation was like its trailer, i wouldn't mind it.

I gave it a 1/10 and dropped it. Personally didn't like the animation/art and I don't feel like watching another edgy/dark anime. I've also heard that they skipped 1-2 arcs already based on the first episode.

[25thIremi]

@themantarays, if you like changing art styles, you should check out Magician by Kim Sarae. The art goes from absolutely horrible to fantastic and through various styles like painting and watercolors.

[gus]

nvm please edit

Edited by gus, 03 July 2016 - 05:13 AM.

[Jorg]

I don't really put that much emphasis on art usually, but there are some things that bother me like Rak being forced into his small compressed form most of the time..And Androssis chest being buffed out because we really need more fanservice apparently...

 

There's a certain charm to the style used in season 1 as well, although you might say it looks less refined.

Edited by Jorg, 03 July 2016 - 01:36 PM.

[Lightprayer]

I like it but I like more the style he had late season 1 and early season 2.

[gus]

 from what i see we all are in the same page in agreement

 

looking closely at SIU art style  he  is using a lot more black in his art panel if i would to show in example style wise it  would be studio Trigger and Gainax and an anime called

Redline