I see why you'd say that, but there's no sense being defeatist about it. It's better to have specific guidelines than otherwise, even if the comment sections may be worse than they were at some past time. If someone's arguing about what you should and shouldn't do, you can always show them the word of the powers that be. If the person doesn't listen, well, at least you tried.
I'm not saying it's a panacea, I just think it would be slightly better than what we have now.
- sjoe likes this