Posted 11 February 2011 - 06:07 AM
Posted 11 February 2011 - 06:09 AM
Posted 11 February 2011 - 10:50 PM
But then this chapter didn't really tell that much so maybe I'm only thinking of something that has a very vague similarity.
Oh well, it's not stopping me from looking forward to the next chapter.
Posted 12 February 2011 - 03:21 AM
Cloudspawn, you're the coolest:
Posted 24 February 2011 - 10:11 AM
The first few chapters were a bit over the top, it felt as though he read this book here and this book here (I have them too), found them super cool and decided to write about them and make a huge deal about them.
It doesn't feel like the author himself is familiar with all these facts. A person who's really acquainted with psychology would probably be embarassed writing just these as "whoa, it's mind-reading!" or the likes. It's like a physics student would never make a big fuss about the fact that when an object falls, it actually Falls Faster as it goes omg! (until it's evened out by friction), it's just too basic.
Also, anybody who's tried these things out in Real life would quickly realize that they don't work out as easily as you think. For example, the woman has her legs crossed and arms crossed. Dr. Frost claims that it can't be because she's cold. Well that's not true. I'm a girl. A girl will have everything crossed on her period for example because it hurts and you want to keep your intestines warm. Legs crossed? She's wearing a mini-skirt! When you want to make sure people aren't having a good look at your underwear, you'd have your legs crossed. I have my legs crossed all the time, some people just find the position more comfortable.
Touching the ear? Yes, there are explanations about touching the ear and such. Well, some people touch the back of their heads all the time. It's not because they're lying, it's because their hair itches. The bag? Whenever I eat out with friends, I put my bag on the nearest available empty seat. Who wants to keep it on the lap all the time?
Then there's the Rorschach test. People actually question how well it works. I tried looking at it, and I saw a butterfly in it at first then a pig head. So? The author is basically making it seem as though the signs are so easy to read, when in reality there are many possible reasons for the same signs. The books I linked to warned of this as well. Even if you can interpret their state of mind, you cannot interpret as easily the Reason for their state of mind. Is he nervous? Maybe he's just shy or needs to go to the bathroom.
Still, the concept has a lot of potential, and since it did make Webtoon from Best Challenge, I'm supposing it gets better. We'll see!
Posted 24 February 2011 - 06:09 PM
Posted 24 February 2011 - 09:42 PM
Posted 25 February 2011 - 12:55 AM
Posted 25 February 2011 - 02:19 AM
Huh, two pig heads... I wonder what it means? Should I mention that specifically, it looks like those pig monsters in Zelda games?
It's not really the profession part that gets to me, it's the reaction of the person being lectured. "ZOMG CRAZY PSYCHO MINDREADING." It's actually have been more convincing if the author toned it down a bit, and explained the other ways the signals can be interpreted (the way the story is written, it seems like he's never tried it himself). You know, it's a bit like reading a story about cooking, and the first-time cook has no problems chopping vegetables and never gets anything burned up.
These kinds of series that sort of... display a profession, whether it be hacker or sports or psychology are NEVER accurate.
Posted 25 February 2011 - 07:55 AM
for example, if u were with a guy u really liked, u wouldn't cross ur leg and face the exit.
Posted 25 February 2011 - 08:37 AM
- It's her normal sitting posture. That's my case. Sitting with legs parallel just doesn't feel good for some. I sit with my legs crossed with my parents too. We're not likes guys who on the contrary would be making certain "parts" uncomfortable by sitting with their legs crossed.
- She's wearing a mini-skirt. The "open" postures Dr. Frost mentioned were all guys. Do you expect a girl with a mini-skirt to sit with her legs open? When you're wearing a mini-skirt, you have to sit with your legs closed Anyway. When the legs are not crossed, there's a risk that when you move around a bit you reveal your underwear by accident. Under such circumstances, it's actually often more comfortable to sit with your legs crossed, you gain the peace of mind from knowing that you won't embarass yourself by accident by flashing your panties.
- She's on her period. When a girl is on her period, she has stomach cramps and she'd want to be warmer than usual. How much warmer? Well many like to hug a heating pad or the likes to ease the pain, so 24 degrees would not be considered warm. In such situations, the girl would be hunched on herself, with both legs and arms crossed. I guess the author isn't a girl though.
Basically, this manhwa does exagerate a lot so far. I did read up that there were reliable ways to estimating a break-up, but it's not this. The study I read up showed No factor was a reliable indicator of separation (whether lies or whatever) except one: contempt. If one person feels contempt for the other, then the relationship is at risk, but it wasn't mentioned here.
The most obvious indicator should have been the fact that she put on her clothes again before leaving to take the call. If she were just going to make a call, she'd at least leave her clothes and maybe her bag there.
This doesn't mean that I'm not interested in the series though, many series start awkward then become better and better as the writer becomes more familiar with the field.
Posted 28 February 2011 - 03:31 AM
Posted 11 March 2011 - 05:47 AM
Anyway, the latest chapters were funny! xD The girl has a few screws loose in her head, and Dr. Frost's "excited" face was hilarious!
Posted 16 March 2011 - 03:09 AM
Hahah! That explanation on professors made me even more confused, since I never went to a U.S. university in the first place, so I have to figure out the practices of Two places now!
Seong-Ah is really a newbie. xD Psychologists aren't supposed to get too close to their patients, it's bad for both of them. That's why psychologists and their patients don't sit face to face, and why friendship between the psychologist and the patient is labeled "dual relationship" and is actually considered unethical (because the friendship relationship can complicate the psychologist-patient relationship, thus making the treatment less effective. You can get mad at a friend and feel betrayed by him, for example).
I don't agree that empathy doesn't exist though, though obviously if Professor Frost doesn't feel any emotions, he can't understand empathy either. Empathy is what friends are for though, not psychologists. xD
The kitty at the end is So cute!
Posted 16 March 2011 - 03:28 AM
Posted 16 March 2011 - 03:43 AM
Posted 16 March 2011 - 05:55 AM
Posted 16 March 2011 - 06:02 AM
Well, psychopathy also implies amoral behavior. Dr. Frost isn't really out to get anyone in particular. He seems more autistic than psychopatic to me, Asperger's Syndrome in particular.
Dr. Frost is a psychopath?
I suspect I was a bit autistic as a kid myself, and pretty bad at reading people's faces. Some people like me try to compensate by reading books on human subjects and trying to apply them. Dr. Frost gives me that impression. He has no inate understanding of people because of his lack of empathy, so he researched human behavior instead and made a mental list of rules.
No, I'm not that extreme. I've found a simpler rule since. I note whatever really bothers me when someone else does it to me, and just assume the same applies to other people. It works pretty well. x)
Posted 17 March 2011 - 01:30 AM
Figure I'll throw out there that most of what Mizura has been saying is spot on - this is not (or should not be) black and white stuff. The only things I've read that suggest these things are always true are pop psychology (and often on TV). I can't wait for someone to bring up personality typology, hahaha.
Althouth this is not necessarily true:
"That's why psychologists and their patients don't sit face to face,..."
It depends on the type of counselling, really. I do agree that the relationship between a therapist and a patient must be cultivated carefully. I seem to remember that some methods of therapy do require a particular relationship to develop, but I'm too lazy to check the details on that.
On a side note, I've developed a creepy little fascination with the purse idea, it being the only idea in the first chapter I hadn't heard of before. I'm constantly noticing where my purse is now; at random intervals of my night out it suddenly occurs to me to check. At one point, I realized I'd placed it between myself and a stranger, when I had the alternate option of putting it between myself and a wall. Of course, this is bad science and could be attributed to be me subconsciously trying to stick it to the idea, but when I'm out with friends I'm generally not thinking about this sort of thing.
Cloudspawn, you're the coolest: