9 replies to this topic

[Iron Man]

Hi. I'm Iron Man. I'm the admininistrator of the Turkish scanlation group Tortuga. I would be thankful if you grant me a Contributor status, please.

[mhh]

Hello Iron Man,

 

please have a look at http://vatoto.com/forums/topic/1525-about-contributor-status-application/ again. You are missing something crucial.

[Iron Man]

I was already uploading mangas with a friend's account. Now I decided to open an account for me and uploaded seven chapters of Hajime no Ippo with this account a short time ago. I think you can look at them as sample. And If you give approval to that chapters, i will be thankful.

Edited by Iron Man, 18 August 2014 - 06:59 PM.

[mhh]

You are still missing something. In a way it's just a technically and not required, but it's to make sure you are aware of and is confident in what you are doing, which is important to us.

Please read thread I linked earlier especially the Red statement part in
that thread

[Iron Man]

Man, I don't understand you. Are you kidding me? I understand there are rules and ı can uploaded seven chapters of Hajime no Ippo. But they're still approve and say you're still missing something, please say a little explanatory.

[mhh]

I'm always serious in my capacity as Batoto Administrator. I will not mock nor intentionally mislead either.

 

Perhaps what I wanted to express was unclear so once again in slightly different words:

 

I want you to read read and understand http://vatoto.com/forums/topic/1525-about-contributor-status-application/ and after that adjust your post in which you request the contributor status to  meet the requirements stated there. I don't think I can say it any clearer than I did before that you are especially missing what is requested by the part in red.

 

If you are still confused, all the information you need to meed my request is here: http://vatoto.com/forums/topic/1525-about-contributor-status-application/ and more specifically in the first post.

 

Regards,

mhh

[Iron Man]

Isn't it apparent that I have read rules and understand them? Being treated like this is not cool. Whatever... I have read and understand your rules and I am aware of the technicalities involved in the uploading process. I hope you are satisfied now.

[mhh]

Isn't it apparent that I have read rules and understand them? Being treated like this is not cool. Whatever... I have read and understand your rules and I am aware of the technicalities involved in the uploading process. I hope you are satisfied now.

No, if you look at it objectively it was not apparent that you have read the rules. Rather the only thing that was apparent was, that you had not read the thread about the contributor status application or at the very least not read carefully enough.

 

The requirement is the same for everybody, I'm not sure why you think I'm mistreating you, wanting you to actually state it like everybody else.

 

The purpose of the requirement that applicants need to state that they have read and understood the rules is

1) to make sure contributors are capable of reading the rules and following them

2) so people know should know when uploading and

3) so they can't shift blame when they did something they shouldn't have (like uploading hentai) by saying they were not aware. (This happens a lot.)

 

But yes, your request meets the minimum requirements now.

[Iron Man]

Okay, I understand. Sorry for my attitude. But I wonder if it is possible to gain contributor status a bit earlier. I heard that these approvals are done in batches, but there are almost 50 manga chapters that are waiting to be uploaded by me. So if you give approval quickly, i will be very thankful.

[mhh]

Approved.