24 replies to this topic

[Viole1369]

Which do you think is best one? and what others are good enough to be called close to best?

 

For me best one is Tower of God

The Gamer in 2nd position 

SID on 3rd along with The God of Highschool

Noblesse at 4th position

and Ability at 5

 

 

What about you guys?

 

(This is allowed right? T_T)

Edited by Viole1369, 17 May 2014 - 07:44 AM.

[Rainblergh]

I like The Gamer best from the ones listed mostly because I still haven't started reading ToG yet >.> But yesterday I also found a very good webtoon named American Ghost Jack I highly reccomend it

[Viole1369]

Horror

Seinin

Supernatural

 

Im tempted..

Try SID

Its horror,mystery,supernatural aswell (seinin too)

[Rainblergh]

Wow seems very nice indeed, I'll read it later when I have time. Nice recommendation o/

[Viole1369]

My pleasure and thanks for yours aswell

[svines85]

Well, the first few that come to (my) mind aren't on your list (1. Annarasumanara 2. The Friendly Winter 3. 3 Level Combination), but of the ones that're listed I'd say Afterschool War Activities, the first season of Tower of God, Trace, the first 53 chapters of Girls of the Wild's and Noblesse .....in that order.  

[Viole1369]

Well, the first few that come to (my) mind aren't on your list (1. Annarasumanara 2. The Friendly Winter 3. 3 Level Combination), but of the ones that're listed I'd say Afterschool War Activities, the first season of Tower of God, Trace, the first 53 chapters of Girls of the Wild's and Noblesse .....in that order.  

Updated the list with them

Afterschool

I stalled it at 16, wasn't getting it into much sadly. Though I plan to continue it some time!

Also have you read the gamer and SID? *-*

[svines85]

Updated the list with them

Afterschool

I stalled it at 16, wasn't getting it into much sadly. Though I plan to continue it some time!

Also have you read the gamer and SID? *-*

I haven't read them, though I've got SID on my list, I just haven't ever gotten to it. Oh well, I will eventually.  

 

And I've heard a lot about The Gamer, though I haven't really thought of trying it. Maybe I should since everyone thinks so highly of it. 

[Viole1369]

I haven't read them, though I've got SID on my list, I just haven't ever gotten to it. Oh well, I will eventually.  

 

And I've heard a lot about The Gamer, though I haven't really thought of trying it. Maybe I should since everyone thinks so highly of it. 

 

Hope you do it soon!

 

And you should

Premise is well - A person suddenly gets his life converted into taht of game char

so everything in MMO (skill,items,monsters,level) comes to reality for him.

 

Its pretty awesome

[clamzoopa]

City of the Dead Sorcerer getting no love...

[Alcruid]

City of the Dead Sorcerer getting no love...

^this

CotDS is my favourite
Then ToG s1/trace

Nowhere boy is also pretty good, but it probably won't ever finish

I have the feeling no one will vote Flow >.>

[Viole1369]

Added CoTS and dw alc flow got a vote

[Antisolar]

In my eyes, the best webtoon are :
Annarasumanara
Hellper
Magician
Knight Run
Kubera
Son Yeon Jeon [Limit]
Tower of God
Trace

Lessa

Like a Bird

I also think that City of the Dead Sorcerer, Red Storm, Paladin, Automata, Pinocchio are noteworthy.
Don't remember enough about SID. I am also certain I am forgetting some webtoon

The ones I enjoy the most atm are :
Noblesse
Tower of God
The Gamer

Black Haze

 

edit 09/03/15 : added a few stuffeh

Edited by Antisolar, 09 March 2015 - 01:50 PM.

[clamzoopa]

^this

CotDS is my favourite
Then ToG s1/trace

Nowhere boy is also pretty good, but it probably won't ever finish

I have the feeling no one will vote Flow >.>

No!  Nowhere Boy is terrible for the reason you stated.  It seemed like it was so close to finishing and it just stopped being translated. TT o TT

 

I'm a little surprised The Gamer got so many votes for the limited number of chapters.  It's just that good.

Edited by clamzoopa, 20 May 2014 - 03:10 PM.

[UnknownSpecimen]

If you liek The Gamer then you'll probably enjoy Dice webtoon.

Edited by UnknownSpecimen, 08 March 2015 - 11:11 AM.

[Yan Q]

I'm a little surprised The Gamer got so many votes for the limited number of chapters.  It's just that good.

As much as I like Noblesse, ToG etc, they've extended themselves far beyond a good webtoon. It gets a little drawn out, and the original plotline gets lost. There's no balance anymore.

I'm liking The Gamer atm. It's original, has good comic relief, but enough plot to keep me hooked in. Not sure how it'll end up, but I hope it ends succinctly and true to it's original story.
I dropped Dice because the character development was starting to irk me.

Annarasumanara was a favourite too because it was really original, and had a good feel to it. The ending was a nice touch as well.

It seems you haven't put in a lot of webtoons in the poll that you might not have read yourself/genre you're familiar with. Things like:
- Cheese in the Trap (CITT)
- Dr. Frost
- Orange Marmalade (not to my liking, but a lot of others like it)
- The Stories of Those Around Me (STAM, a true slice of life)
- Witch Hunt (going pretty well)

If at all possible, I'd like to nominate Space Boy. It's not a traditional webtoon, and it's actually one of Naver's new ones from the Challenge, but I've been following it from the beginning and Stephen is top notch.

Edited by Yan Q, 09 March 2015 - 02:13 AM.

[Shiina]

I dropped ToG a while back, thinking it went down a sad path, much alike Noblesse. 
I then dropped The God of Highschool. The pacing just went all over the place. It became messy.
I tried Flow but damn, it was so fastpaced and nothing made any real sense and the author went all sorts of places and aah, it was a mess. Really.


The Gamer is nice, if you can handle the stale artstyle. It really looks stiff and the dynamic just isn't there. It's good nonetheless.
About Death, literally had me in tears for the short ride it provided. Highly reccomend it, it's about 20 chapters long, half of them being shorter as they are a "prelude" or theme setter for the next chapter or something along those lines. 
If you enjoyed The Stories of Those Around Me, check out Salty Studio, made by the same person. You can really feel the similarities and there's even a few crossmentions. 
I Don't Want This Kind of Hero is quickly rising for me aswell.... The MC is hillariously dynamic.
Legendary Moon Sculptor is ok, the MC is a bit uninteresting though. Probably will develop his character later, looking forward to it. 

Special Martial Arts Extreme Hell Private High School is going up and down. Some chapters are just... meh and some a golden. I keep reading it for those golden ones. 
Afterschool Military Activities was a wild ride. It was great. Very dynamic characters. I reccomend it along with 3 Level Combination. Also very vivid characters.
Aura From Another Planet started out great, then.. I don't know anymore. It feels generic at times even when it's so unique.

Should I rank them it's probably
1/2 About Death, The Gamer
3/4 Salty Studio, I Don't Want This Kind of Hero
5/6 After School Military Activities, 3 Level Combination.

[jaejoong]

Cheese in the Trap.  Yoojung was just 

[vagabond]

I like Dead days. The gamer is not bad though (great moments of comedy in the first chapters). But tower of god, still don't understand why this comic works...

[raisane]

I vote for orange marmalade