3 replies to this topic

[Naselare]

Here is a list of chapters that have inconsistencies/mistakes.

Wrong groups:
The following were not done by "Animum Mutare" but by "Reddevilshn".
Chapter 291
Chapter 293
Chapter 294
Chapter 295
Chapter 297
Chapter 298
Chapter 299
Chapter 300
Chapter 302
Chapter 303
Chapter 304
Chapter 305
Chapter 306
Chapter 307
(kind of felt insulted for all these)

The following were not done by "Animum Mutare" but by "Lion of Genesis".
Chapter 296

(My releases of those chapters are in fact, nowhere to be seen here on Batoto.)
MangaToshokan did not allow me to upload/update my releases if they were uploaded by someone else, so I'm just making sure that these aren't going to be a problem. By the way, being able to identify a scan as LQ, MQ, MQ/HQ and HQ would be a nice feature.

Chapters taken from some other online reader and uploaded here (seriously now?!):
Chapter 280
Chapter 281
Chapter 320

(I'm still checking around for other mistakes. Please be aware that if I upload a chapter that's already up here and by the same group, it's for updating/fixing purposes.)

[Grumpy]

Thanks for reporting.

reddevilshin/lion of genesis ones have been fixed.

I'm not sure what you mean by 280 and 281 as they seem fine to me.

The noted chapter 320 has been removed. Ishkar was likely uploading masses of chapters he had saved in his harddrive. There was a proper chapter 320 already uploaded anyway by another contributor.

Yes, you may reupload to update/replace the old series.

And lastly, batoto works on a system of continued group reading. Not a preference via quality of the scans. For example, if there is chapter 10 by group A and group B and you were reading chapter 9 by group A, the "next" chapter is chapter 10 by group A regardless of other factors. This allows a more consistent read as the style of the translation, naming, etc will stay consistent.

The question of what is low-high is subjective. There are scans which have superior resolution and and cleaning job, but sometimes lacks in fidelity of the language. Sometimes vice versa. To justify what is low/high purely based on the quality of the physical scan itself may misrepresent the true quality of the workmanship.

[Ishkar]

Everything up to 316 was pulled off of mangastop.net, which just offers downloads of long running series. Sorry about messing up the credits, by the end of that I was kind of spaced out. I'll start reading through it to see if I made any more mistakes.

Edit
I see what I did. Animum Mutare Reddevilshn. I saw that your groups had the same translator and same raw provider and assumed that you were the same group. Sorry again.

[Naselare]

lastly, batoto works on a system of continued group reading. Not a preference via quality of the scans. For example, if there is chapter 10 by group A and group B and you were reading chapter 9 by group A, the "next" chapter is chapter 10 by group A regardless of other factors. This allows a more consistent read as the style of the translation, naming, etc will stay consistent.

The question of what is low-high is subjective. There are scans which have superior resolution and and cleaning job, but sometimes lacks in fidelity of the language. Sometimes vice versa. To justify what is low/high purely based on the quality of the physical scan itself may misrepresent the true quality of the workmanship.

Ah yes, I'm very aware. I was just accustomed to how the uploading system at MT is, as I could easily tell how worth uploading a chapter (already present in the list of chapters) was. But I think it's fine either way - A suggestion is just a suggestion, after all.

By the way, regarding Chapters 280 and 281, they were done by a group Called "White wings". That group didn't upload their releases anywhere, with the exception of OneManga. Naturally, the pages were compressed and saved as low-quality JPG files before they were put up on OneManga. Chapter 320 was a similar case, but this time the release was put up on MangaFox instead.

EDIT:

Everything up to 316 was pulled off of mangastop.net, which just offers downloads of long running series. Sorry about messing up the credits, by the end of that I was kind of spaced out. I'll start reading through it to see if I made any more mistakes.

It's fine, don't worry about it. Check the mediafire folder just in case.