Persona 5

 I fail to see how those r plot holes.

Spoiler

What do you mean with b4 the game even starts? Akechi already stalked the group in the second palace.

How would the group know the principal is connected to the antagonist?

 As for Medjed, the original Medjed was Futaba herself and her online friends. The fake medjed group were the ones who went against PF and had connections to Shido.

seems you forget that medjed is a collective and not an individual.

A disbanded group, none of whose members were ever caught and completely and utterly unrelated anything in the game other than being scapegoats used by the antagonist. But lets blame the Phantom Thieves, amirite?

While we're at it, lets arrest Ronald Reagan, shoot him up full of drugs and then force him to sign a prearranged confession stating that he's part of the global conspiracy to put Donald Trump in power or we'll break his legs. That makes sense right?

 

 

How Medjed is allowed to run free for 2 years but the moment the Phantom Thieves become involved, the entire country loses their collective shit, to say nothing of how Medjed's threats undermines the entire global economy?

seems you forget that medjed is a collective and not an individual.

Sae and Akechi suspecting the Phantom Thieves for the deaths/mental shutdowns/scandals/coverups for the 2 years before the game even starts with absolutely no basis whatsoever?

 

How something as goddamn simple as checking the principal's phone records, would've led to the main antagonist almost immediately?

 

How Medjed is allowed to run free for 2 years but the moment the Phantom Thieves become involved, the entire country loses their collective shit, to say nothing of how Medjed's threats undermines the entire global economy?

 I fail to see how those r plot holes.

Maybe hold off on spoilers for the whole story in the comment section of a manga that only has a single chapter out?

What were the plotholes? They really explained things in details so it could very well be possible you missed it

Sae and Akechi suspecting the Phantom Thieves for the deaths/mental shutdowns/scandals/coverups for the 2 years before the game even starts with absolutely no basis whatsoever?

How something as goddamn simple as checking the principal's phone records, would've led to the main antagonist almost immediately?

How Medjed is allowed to run free for 2 years but the moment the Phantom Thieves become involved, the entire country loses their collective shit, to say nothing of how Medjed's threats undermines the entire global economy?

Ah yes, the first official source for the Protagonist's established name.

Hope they make it the canon name if they ever release one, I don't know why but it just feels right.

hell yeahhhh
thx for translating guys

P5's story is good, but it has some pretty massive plotholes.

 

That said, its very stylish and quite good overall, but I disagree with Siquall. Its not a masterpiece. Games don't become masterpieces just by adding more in its sequel.

What were the plotholes? They really explained things in details so it could very well be possible you missed it

Ah yes, the first official source for the Protagonist's established name.

Its not a masterpiece. Games don't become masterpieces just by adding more in its sequel.

He didn't say anything about the game becoming masterpiece because it's the latest entry in the franchise tho.

My thoughts? Totally recommended buy, but personally the bosses' design are inferior to the past entries.

so they make manga for this game too

to anyone that play this game, is it good? in terms of story

i don't have ps3 or ps4 so can't play this game unless they make it to vita at least

 

personally i like p3's story better than p4's story, i'm curious in p5's story

P5's story is good, but it has some pretty massive plotholes.

That said, its very stylish and quite good overall, but I disagree with Siquall. Its not a masterpiece. Games don't become masterpieces just by adding more in its sequel.

Personally, the stories that were best in the series were the Persona 2 duology. I can't even describe how batshit insane it got. You had, among other things,

Adolf Hitler as a boss wielding the Lance of Longinus, a UFO buried under Tokyo powered by rumors, Leyline dragons that devour hate energy, and the main

villain that is so certain of victory that he opens up a shop in disguise to aid you just for shits and giggles. 

Also, the Engrish was hilarious too

"Let's positive thinking!"

I named my guy Kurogane Kai, personally.

so they make manga for this game too

to anyone that play this game, is it good? in terms of story

i don't have ps3 or ps4 so can't play this game unless they make it to vita at least

 

personally i like p3's story better than p4's story, i'm curious in p5's story

It's not only good, it's a masterpiece , the best jrpg on consoles since the end of ps2.

 

Characters and story are better than P4 too, it was a little too much shonen-like for me.

 

Buy the game if you can.

IMO while the story is quite good, I don't think it really picks up until after you beat the boss that attacks you with Happy Meals. And there is a rather blatant gap revolving around a certain character that Atlus will no doubt revisit with an expanded edition. Nier Automata also has a great story and gameplay.

(Eh even though P3s story is great not going to lie, I liked P4s a bit more for personal reasons. Though its not sayin much for me.)

Like Siquall said the story is pretty great, one of the series best in my opinion, though Sep has a bit of a point that it doesn't pick up until a certain point for some people. 

While waiting for a PS Vita versions an okay thought, try to find a ps3 with a good price and get it while you can ( Hell and if your lucky get a PS4 with a reasonable price). Cause and aside from I guess Nier Auto (havent actually played it personally though looking at some playthourghs it does look like a great game) Its worth your time and money.    

It's not only good, it's a masterpiece , the best jrpg on consoles since the end of ps2.
 
Characters and story are better than P4 too, it was a little too much shonen-like for me.
 
Buy the game if you can.

so they make manga for this game too

to anyone that play this game, is it good? in terms of story

i don't have ps3 or ps4 so can't play this game unless they make it to vita at least

 

personally i like p3's story better than p4's story, i'm curious in p5's story

It's not only good, it's a masterpiece , the best jrpg on consoles since the end of ps2.

Characters and story are better than P4 too, it was a little too much shonen-like for me.

Buy the game if you can.

so they make manga for this game too

to anyone that play this game, is it good? in terms of story

i don't have ps3 or ps4 so can't play this game unless they make it to vita at least

personally i like p3's story better than p4's story, i'm curious in p5's story