Sign In
Create Account
(4.3 - 123votes)
Class ga Isekai Shoukan sareta Naka Ore dake Nokotta n desu ga
| Alt Names: |  クラスが異世界召喚されたなか俺だけ残ったんですが My Entire Class Was Summoned to Another World except for Me |
| Author: | Southern Terrace |
| Artist: | Kiku Ueda |
| Genres: |  Action Drama Fantasy Harem Romance School Life Shounen Supernatural |
| Type: | Manga (Japanese) |
| Status: | Ongoing |
| Description: | A god of a different world had abruptly appeared in Kamiya Yato's classroom and forcibly summoned the entire class to his world... except for him—because he was sleeping in a seat in the corner of the class, the round summoning magic circle didn't reach him—and he ended up staying here on Earth, but with brand-new skills. After he made it through a whole year full of police interviews and journalism reports, he finally became a high school student, but the quiet days he had hoped for were far from over—be it terrorists who decide to occupy his school or even monsters from different world, one by one new incidents take place in the town he lives in... Will a boy without any motivation be able to save the world? |
| Go to Class ga Isekai Shoukan sareta Naka Ore dake Nokotta n desu ga Forums! | Scroll Down to Comments | |
Latest Forum Posts
| Topic | Started By | Stats | Last Post Info | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
Web Novel  |
shizuku kyun |
|
|
Start New Topic
Highest Rated Series
98 Comments
Well, it's a spoiler.
Details:
interesting, that's a pretty big assumption, don't you think?
let's comment so the wall of text doesn't appear on the front page of this interesting manga.
I don't know either they went and killed the Demon King and find out that they actually can't get back to their world, they're enslaved as "heroes" and forced to fight against their will, or they just get killed cuz modern people who live in really peaceful times and countries can't handle the sudden shift to a full-on kill or be killed medieval mentality at the drop of a hat.
I still can't digest what the hell just happened.... What happened to the others that got summoned to the other world?
So he turned to a magical girl?
Oh dude THIS comments....but I just wanna know if there are lots of naked women.
And I mean the sexy ones.Certain recent chapter in Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san put on guard about being specific in the matter.. .
you know what? you should made that a God damn story!
sometime, we need story that have realistic approach.
well, that's how internet works. people have so much free time.
being "generic" is okay, it's matter how you execute the story, how you fleshing out character development, how the story flow. Being "cliche" is okay too, sometime it's necessary to keep the story move BUT! it must not being used repetitively to the point turn into DEUS EX MACHINA PLOT or VERY THICK PLOT ARMOR that's the major let down of the story. There should be balance in the story.
yeah, it was laid on the consumers. Anything that popular they are going to milk it till it died, they fear publishing something new might lead them lose with other publisher. This is why so many publisher in Japan mass producing thing kind of story, because Market still on demand of Isekai story.
There is few attempt to restore the "fantasy" genre without "Isekai". It was worked well, but not yet able to defeat the "Isekai" genre. You may have know it, like Deep in Abyss, Mahou Tsukai no Yome, Grencrest Senki, Helk and many more. It was a story that start with pure Fantasy. once again, sadly it's not entirely popular that able to defeat Isekai genre since the market still like Isekai.
It was rare to find WN with decent story, since WN was like rough sketch of drawing. it needs to be polished more (but some time it still shitty).
I think everyone already know Overlord LN, the WN was at best mediocore, compared the LN which already being polished and more refined, this one just one example that there is great difference between WN and LN release.
But some LN have not much different compared the WN like ... what is it again? the character that have white hair and use revolver named donder or something, heck I forgot that shit name. well whatever.
anyway ... ...
I guess I'm a bit derailed from the topic so, I'll end my comment here.
not sarcastic ... the idea sounds really interesting, why don't you try it? (from that essay I got the feeling you do something related to that)
also an idea:
- making a realist approach to other world... not having magic and the isekai'd guy has to go to school/college/work as a normal person and can't go for the usual cliches (weapons or power that military has in possesion doesn't get to him)
about the publisher part, the difference between western and eastern (mostly japanese) publishers are the consumers they have... this type of stories, going full chuunibyou are well liked there, they really like those mary sue, they like the robotic harem members, it's a thing that a part of the public loves to self-insert in power-fantasy stories. (probably the level of stress in there in their day-to-day life)
this was just released, HTF did it make 4 pages already?? (probably 3 are about shitting isekai more than shitting this series ... I was close hahaha)
.....I did. I would think anyone else with an ounce of critical thought wouldn't find that 'essay' disagreeable especially in the context of it being a detailed response to some other commentor. Guess we just have too much spare mental capacity to overly analysis a topic as as opposed to just having a generic interest summed up by the throw away line TL:DR.
I've read the majority what's out for the WN of this series through MTL. (Just 4 chapters behind.)
Main piece of advice: Don't expect any real sense of crisis from this series, just treat as a slice of life with an OP MC. Since it's not entirely clear from his skill names at the end of the first chapter, he has a spell that he casts before going to sleep that lets him gain experience from sleeping, which is how he's leveled up. (I think it's the one that's translated as "Super Reinforced Sleep Magic", maybe "Extreme Growth Sleep Magic" would have been better?)
There's back story behind the summoning, but this contains massive spoilers, and some speculation on my part.
lmao nice essay dude, you think people are actually gonna read this
it's not rocket science that 90% isekai are shit, why write this long ass essay calling a spade a spade? I think you're the only one that cares this much
If i wanted to use the premise of "everyone else in my class got isekaied except me!" then I would avoid the mistake of giving the MC any powers at all. I mean, the ENTIRE POINT of not getting isekaied is that you dont get the usual isekai powers, and the story should be about how the MC and those left behind move on. There are so many options available from here on.
Just off the top of my head
-MC doesn't get isekaied (its ambigious whether its on purpose or not)
-MC's life turns into shit because everyone thinks he had something to do with his classmates dissapearing
-MC constantly regrets not getting isekaied with them
>some of his classmates manage to come back temporarily, but for various reasons cant stay
>unfortunately some demons followed them too and the MC witnesses them fighting
>MC regrets ot getting isekaied again because his classmates look so cool like it's a video game, up till the point where one of them gets badly injured/dies
>his classmates tell him a bit of the other world, its pretty shitty and some of the class have already died
>they tell him that they have a plan to escape back here but it needs more work and they need his help
>MC has to struggle with helping him or not because his relationship with the rest of the class wasn't perfect and theres nobody in his class that he wants to risk his life for
>interject scenes of the MC meeting the parents of the missing kids, etc
Instead we get :
>MC doesnt get isekaied
>Gets OP powers anyway
>video game mechanics
>instant love interest
>takes out terrorists because LOL LEVEL 90+ OP
>MC is so cool and perfect, can sleep in class and ace every test!
>don't you just want to be the MC???
Its not about being "generic". Take the Black Clover manga for example. Its a generic battle shounen that is at best, average. Its got the typical "hard working disadvantaged MC vs talented rival" thing. Art is mediocre. Everything else is average or below. That said, its not garbage, its just mediocre.
Things that make a series garbage are things that would instantly fail you in writing class, because they break the basic rules of writing. Some examples :
>MC is a mary sue with OP powers
>Deus ex machina, like the MC being chosen by god to get reincarnated because "lol you got lucky!!!"
>The MC is blatantly the author's self insert
>Everyone instantly worships the MC except for the badly written, puppy kicking villains who want to take over the world mwahahahha!
>Characters have one dimensional personalities, like the girls in the MC's harem who cant do anything except lust for his cock and fight with the other girls
>female characters are best remembered by their breast size or revealing clothes rather than who they are and their accomplishments
>The MC's love interests love him forever despite him making no effort in the relationship or even acknowledging that there IS a relationship. In other words, characters behave more like robots programed to fulfill the MC's will rather than actual, living, people.
>Handwaving away character development by using video game mechanics. Why put in effort to describe the MC getting stronger when you can just have him level up right?
>The MC conveniently walking in on naked girls who fall madly in love with him a few pages later and other ridiculous, unbelivable, scenarios that are simply convenient for the author.
>Ridiculous settings that makes no sense, like putting high schoolers in charge of weapons more powerful than what the military can use, followed by them having tournament battles in a high school setting where, conveniently, nobody ever dies and no parents flip out at their kids being placed in danger on a daily basis.
>the story consists of the MC using his OP powers to impress girls, who remain madly in love with him forever despite him showing zero interest in them
>the art is SO BAD that characters all have pure white skin because the artist could not be bothered with skin tones or shading
You get the idea. These are plot elements that seem "cool"...WHEN YOU ARE 12 YEARS OLD....and fantasizing while bored in class. When you get older, you naturally realise that your 12 year old fantasies were incredibly cringey and embarrassing, and never speak of them to anyone.
The execution is also important. Here's an example...Saitama is OP. BUT he's also bald, he gets no respect from almost everyone, he literally has like one friend...Genos is his "disciple" and people like Bang are co-workers and acquaintances at best. Only King could be considered his friend and he's a NEET fraudster and it's a miracle he hasn't gotten anyone killed yet because they thought he could save them (which he can't). The story doesn't focus on Saitama and side characters get far more page time than he does. He has tons of flaws and constantly displays undesirable traits such as rudeness and apathy.
Meanwhile, your typical mary sue MC would be the focus of every chapter, would have pretty much no or only insignificant flaws, women would flock to him in droves, he can do no wrong, everyone worships him, he coasts through life with ease, he's literally THE CHOSEN ONE, he has a [ skill ] for every situation...
Imagine how god awful Re:Zero would be if Reinhard was a Japanese highschooler and the MC. Thats what most Isekai stories are like. Know why Re:Zero is so popular? The MC doesnt have OP powers and cant solve things just by using some cheat skill.
All of these are very very basic things that every author should know. You dont even need to take a writing class for this, its something you can google in a few minutes. Yet more than 95% of the isekai series on this site breaks half a dozen or more of these rules.
The use of video game mechanics in particular is nothing more than an excuse to make life easy for the author. You can easily sum up the MC's growth by having him level up or obtain some OP skill. Without video game mechanics, the author would have to write more than one sentence to describe the MC getting stronger or smarter. One series that impressed me with how the author did character development was "Darwin's game". The MC was your typical whiney highschooler, entered a death game, fought for his life and eventually developed into a confident and clever character who constantly plans and uses everything to his advantage. The death game had video game mechanics, but the author didn't simply give the MC some OP skill or increase his level....he had the MC grow as a person to make full use of allies, the environment and the rules of the game to get stronger.
You will notice that almost all Isekai series on this site NEVER do this. They just have the MC be OP from the beginning and beat up badly written villains while making girls wet. There is zero character development other than their levels/stats getting higher, getting even more OP skills or having more women throw themselves at him while he either remains aloof or reacts with horror at physical contact with a female. The character itself remains the same from start to finish...a high schooler given godlike powers with the mentality of a high schooler.
It is very, very, obvious which series have actual effort put into them by the author, right from chapter 1. Take THIS series for example. Right from chapter one, you know its just going to be the MC flexing his muscles while looking bored, impressing girls and saving the day. Compare that to chapter one of "Black Company". You can easily tell that more planning and effort has been put into the series from the very beginning and that the characters actually resemble real people...with realistic motivations, goals and actions.
I just do not see how garbage like this gets accepted at a publisher without connections or bribery. Look at western writing forums where current and prospective writers discuss their work...the barrier to getting a simple story published is insanely high and many prospective writers have to submit dozens of drafts to get their first story published. Needless to say, the quality of their writing far exceeds this level, yet, this garbage somehow gets published instead?
I mean, really, can any of you name a single western publisher, that would publish garbage like this? Please name one, because I would love to submit the typical isekai story to them and see their response.
I agree with most of your comment, but your negative take on generic.
I'd say that many people overreact to isekai these days. Like you i'm willing to invest my time in this series.
I like the first chapter but am not sure if the story can keep being interesting in the future so I looked it up in NU reviews and every single one of my fears seems to come true. That's depressing... but not so much as the Comment section. So let's mix my own opinion in
I do have my fair share of troubles with isekai. That being for :
But one can still find a rare gem. It also looks like we are going too see an increase in original fantasy thanks to isekai.
I was with you on for the longest part until you bring out my two most hated and reoccurring arguments.
Granted something being popular can be an indicator for it being good but there is always the chance that it is just some mainstream easy to take in, generic work in which somehow everybody can find something to like in. For example you will often hear rap heads calling mumble rap cancer (and it is) but a lot of people get into it whom would otherwise not listen to rap at all (it's also not as bad when your drunk
).
Finally do I have to be an author to rate another authors work? It does help but it is not a necessity especially as the target group. Same with sports or any other job or hobby. You will sometimes see them make blatant mistakes
Generic af but at least it's an interesting setting (nothing else seems remarkable so far tho).
followed, let's see where it goes
Amusing idea, need to see further though.
Nobody said there was an issue with Isekai, the problem is when its garbage. I mean, think about it...this is the kind of stuff that high school teachers would have issues with.
But there is someone at fault. Its the fault of the author, its the fault of the publisher who agreed to publish it and its the fault of people who keep buying it, thereby giving incentive to rerpeat the cycle.
What the actual fuck was this exposition page. "Hmm yeah be careful out there ALSO TERRORISTS."